GAAR Grandfathering Restored: CBDT Responds to Tiger Global, but Only Partly Published: 2026-04-08 Category: Bottom Line Source: https://resolutpartners.com/research/gaar-grandfathering-restored-cbdt-responds-to-tiger-global-but-only-partly Authors: Agrim Mor, Hrishikesh Anand Background For years, foreign investors structuring their India investments through Mauritius relied on a clear framework: (i) a valid TRC was sufficient proof of residency, and (ii) investments made before April 1, 2017 were protected from GAAR under Rule 10U(1)(d) The Supreme Court recently disrupted this with its ruling in Tiger Global. It differentiated between pre-2017 “investments” and “arrangements,” declaring that Tiger’s Mauritius structure was an impermissible arrangement under GAAR, even though the investments were made between 2011 and 2015 While the widespread view was that pre-2017 investments were grandfathered, the SC referred to the text of the law to bring pre-2017 investments within GAAR’s reach As discussed in our analysis (https://resolutpartners.com/research/tiger-flipkart-rewriting-the-rules-of-treaty-interpretation-with-renewed-nationalism) of the Tiger ruling, we had concerns with the court’s distinction between “investments” and “arrangements”. In our view, the threshold for treating a structure as an ‘arrangement’ should be significantly higher – closer to a sham The SC’s ruling was also being read with a degree of finality, despite only being the court’s view on the AAR’s a prima facie rejection of Tiger’s application for an advance ruling The CBDT has now stepped in, amending the IT Rules to clarify that GAAR cannot be applied to pre-2017 investments Bottom Line The revised Rule 10U(2) of the IT Rules, 1962/ Rule 128 of the IT Rules, 2026 expressly state that GAAR applies to any arrangement irrespective of date, except for income from transfer of investments made before 1 April 2017. Previously, the law did not protect pre-2017 investments from GAAR scrutiny The amendment is a welcome step, restoring the intended grandfathering position by offering relief to foreign investors with pre2017 investments. This mitigates GAAR scrutiny risk for investors exiting pre-2017 investments However, the amendment only addresses the GAAR grandfathering issue. Other implications of the Tiger Global ruling still stand: a TRC may no longer be enough to prove residency, potentially leading to increased scrutiny of the place of effective management and tax liability; Article 13(4) of the India-Mauritius DTAA may not extend to indirect transfers, which could make treaty relief more difficult for multi-layered structures; JAAR continues to apply independently, meaning treaty benefits could be denied even without invoking GAAR It is also unclear whether this amendment will provide relief to Tiger Global, since the SC also relied on indirect transfers, substance, and residency to arrive at its judgment – none of which have been affected by this notification