GAAR Grandfathering Restored: CBDT Responds to Tiger Global, but Only Partly

8 April 2026

Background

  • For years, foreign investors structuring their India investments through Mauritius relied on a clear framework: (i) a valid TRC was sufficient proof of residency, and (ii) investments made before April 1, 2017 were protected from GAAR under Rule 10U(1)(d)
  • The Supreme Court recently disrupted this with its ruling in Tiger Global. It differentiated between pre-2017 “investments” and “arrangements,” declaring that Tiger’s Mauritius structure was an impermissible arrangement under GAAR, even though the investments were made between 2011 and 2015
  • While the widespread view was that pre-2017 investments were grandfathered, the SC referred to the text of the law to bring pre-2017 investments within GAAR’s reach
  • As discussed in our analysis of the Tiger ruling, we had concerns with the court’s distinction between “investments” and “arrangements”. In our view, the threshold for treating a structure as an ‘arrangement’ should be significantly higher – closer to a sham
  • The SC’s ruling was also being read with a degree of finality, despite only being the court’s view on the AAR’s a prima facie rejection of Tiger’s application for an advance ruling
  • The CBDT has now stepped in, amending the IT Rules to clarify that GAAR cannot be applied to pre-2017 investments

Bottom Line

  • The revised Rule 10U(2) of the IT Rules, 1962/ Rule 128 of the IT Rules, 2026 expressly state that GAAR applies to any arrangement irrespective of date, except for income from transfer of investments made before 1 April 2017. Previously, the law did not protect pre-2017 investments from GAAR scrutiny
  • The amendment is a welcome step, restoring the intended grandfathering position by offering relief to foreign investors with pre2017 investments. This mitigates GAAR scrutiny risk for investors exiting pre-2017 investments
  • However, the amendment only addresses the GAAR grandfathering issue. Other implications of the Tiger Global ruling still stand:
  1. a TRC may no longer be enough to prove residency, potentially leading to increased scrutiny of the place of effective management and tax liability;
  2. Article 13(4) of the India-Mauritius DTAA may not extend to indirect transfers, which could make treaty relief more difficult for multi-layered structures;
  3. JAAR continues to apply independently, meaning treaty benefits could be denied even without invoking GAAR
  • It is also unclear whether this amendment will provide relief to Tiger Global, since the SC also relied on indirect transfers, substance, and residency to arrive at its judgment – none of which have been affected by this notification

Authors

Agrim Mor

Agrim Mor

Hrishikesh Anand

Hrishikesh Anand


Recent Research

View All →

Loading recent analysis...

Ft Award

Only Indian law firm commended for Innovation in ‘Dealmaking’ category at the FT Innovative Lawyers Awards Asia-Pacific 2024


Join our Whatsapp Community

Click here or scan the QR code to join our WhatsApp community

WhatsApp QR Code